What the new D&D movie captures and misses about the game

CEO Tam DT
If you're a Dungeons & Dragons fan, you've likely experienced disappointment with past movies based on the beloved role-playing game. However, the new film, Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves, is a critical hit. It's...

If you're a Dungeons & Dragons fan, you've likely experienced disappointment with past movies based on the beloved role-playing game. However, the new film, Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves, is a critical hit. It's not only fun and funny, but it also authentically captures the essence of D&D.

Even if you know nothing about the game, you can still enjoy this movie. The directors, Jonathan Goldstein and John Francis Daley, who are longtime D&D players themselves, have skillfully avoided the pitfalls of previous adaptations. They have simplified complex gameplay concepts to make them accessible to a wide audience while still staying true to the game's rules.

The movie is filled with fan-service references and Easter eggs, but it doesn't alienate newcomers. In fact, it has become a box office success, appealing to both existing fans and those new to the world of D&D. The creators' love for the game shines through, creating a welcoming and enjoyable experience for all.

How D&D: Honor Among Thieves captures the heart of the game

One particular scene in the movie resonated strongly with D&D players. It involves the adventuring party receiving a lengthy lecture on how to navigate a trap-filled bridge, only for one character to casually step on it, causing it to collapse. This unexpected and chaotic moment reflects the unpredictable nature of real D&D games. It's these moments that make the game exciting and memorable.

However, the movie does have its flaws. The pacing can feel fast and uneven, and some plot choices may leave even hardcore fans questioning their relevance. The abundance of story crammed into the film almost makes it feel like a season of a TV show. But this is good news for fans, as Paramount+ is working on a D&D series.

The film also addresses the problematic history of D&D and strives to be more inclusive and representative. Many players today are actively reimagining the game to make it more equitable, using tools like player-created content. This agency to tell diverse stories and push the boundaries of the game is what keeps D&D evolving.

The movie's transformative properties honor the spirit of D&D

One of the most magical aspects of D&D is how it allows players to transform themselves. They start with one set of objectives but often find that their characters and motivations change over the course of the game. Honor Among Thieves embraces this transformative quality.

Each character in the movie undergoes personal growth and change, which sets it apart from typical Hollywood ensemble pieces. These complex relationships and motivations reflect the depth of a well-crafted RPG. D&D games, when done right, allow players to explore different aspects of themselves and create profoundly valuable experiences.

D&D's cultural resurgence and its journey towards inclusion

D&D has historically been associated with a specific demographic – conservative white men. But times are changing, and the game is becoming more inclusive. The movie features a diverse cast, showcasing the players who make up the modern D&D community.

This shift is partly due to the representation of D&D in popular culture, as seen in shows like Community and Stranger Things. These portrayals have helped break down stereotypes and attract a wider audience. D&D is no longer solely the domain of cishet-white-teenage-boys-in-the-basement; it is a game for everyone.

However, D&D still has its problems, rooted in its past. These issues are being addressed, with efforts to rethink game material that could reinforce oppressive behaviors. The goal is to create games that celebrate diversity and make everyone feel welcome and included.

Embracing the future of D&D

The release of Honor Among Thieves presents an opportunity for D&D to attract new players and broaden its cultural impact. By combining fun and spectacle, the movie aims to introduce the hobby to a wider audience and open the door for new perspectives and cultural experiences.

While the movie may idealize the D&D experience, it celebrates the joy and creativity that comes from playing the game. It reminds us that, deep down, we're all just kids with foolish plans. And when we come together as a group, even the wildest ideas can lead to victory.

So, whether you're a seasoned D&D player or a curious newcomer, Honor Among Thieves offers an entertaining and authentic portrayal of the game. It captures the spirit of adventure, camaraderie, and personal growth that make D&D a beloved pastime for millions of players worldwide.

1